Skip to main content
1346-1353

The Black Death

It killed one in three Europeans. The survivors demanded higher wages

Pieter Brueghel the Elder, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Open

On the fourteenth of February, thirteen forty nine, Strasbourg took its Jewish community to the cemetery and burned two thousand people alive.

The plague had not reached Strasbourg yet. It arrived months later.

That same week the council divided the dead's property among the citizens and cancelled the debts the citizens owed them.

The Black Death is remembered as the moment Europe lost its mind. A panic does not keep a ledger.

Scene 1Messina, October thirteen forty seven

Twelve Genoese trading ships come into the Sicilian port of Messina. Most of the sailors aboard are already dead.

The ones still alive are covered in black boils that ooze blood and pus.

The harbor authorities order the ships back out to sea. It is too late.

Within six months the plague is in Genoa, in Venice, in Marseilles. By thirteen forty nine it is in England, Germany and Scandinavia. By thirteen fifty one, Moscow.

What was moving was a bacterium. Yersinia pestis, identified in two thousand and eleven from teeth in mass graves, carried by fleas that lived on black rats that lived on ships.

It came in three forms. In the lymph nodes it raised the swellings called buboes and killed inside a week. In the lungs it spread on the breath and killed in two to three days.

In the blood it could kill in hours, before a single symptom showed.

Panoramic painting depicting an army of skeletons devastating a landscape, reflecting the cultural trauma of recurring plague outbreaks in Europe. Painted c. 1562, two centuries after the Black Death, showing how deeply the pandemic embedded itself in European consciousness.
Panoramic painting depicting an army of skeletons devastating a landscape, reflecting the cultural trauma of recurring plague outbreaks in Europe. Painted c. 1562, two centuries after the Black Death, showing how deeply the pandemic embedded itself in European consciousness.Pieter Brueghel the Elder, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (c. 1562)

Scene 2The arithmetic

Europe held about seventy five million people before the plague. By thirteen fifty three it held between thirty and fifty million.

In Cairo the historian al-Maqrizi records ten to twenty thousand dead a day at the peak.

In Avignon, where the papacy sat, the cemeteries overflowed, and Pope Clement the Sixth consecrated the river Rhone so that bodies could be thrown into it.

In Siena, Agnolo di Tura wrote down what he had done himself, because no gravedigger would come.

Agnolo di Tura · Sienese Chronicle · c. 1348

“And I, Agnolo di Tura, buried my five children with my own hands. And there were also those who were so sparsely covered with earth that the dogs dragged them forth.”

“There was no one who wept for any death, for all awaited death.”

Woodcut illustration of the Dance of Death, showing skeletons dancing with living people of all social ranks (pope, king, merchant, peasant), a motif that emerged directly from the Black Death and became a staple of late medieval European art.
Woodcut illustration of the Dance of Death, showing skeletons dancing with living people of all social ranks (pope, king, merchant, peasant), a motif that emerged directly from the Black Death and became a staple of late medieval European art.Michael Wolgemut, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (1493)

Scene 3Paris, October thirteen forty eight

King Philip the Sixth asks the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Paris to explain the pestilence.

The cause, it reports, is a conjunction of Saturn, Jupiter and Mars in the sign of Aquarius, drawing poisoned vapors up out of the land and the sea.

Behind the astrology sits the real conviction. God has sent this for human sin.

The flagellants cross Germany, the Low Countries and Hungary. Two hundred to three hundred men enter a city, whip themselves bloody for thirty three days, one for each year of Christ's life, then move on.

Scene 4Chillon, and what was copied out of it

In September thirteen forty eight, Jews held in the castle of Chillon on Lake Geneva are tortured until they confess to poisoning the wells.

The confession is taken from a surgeon named Balavigny, then copied and forwarded town to town, and it crosses Europe faster than the plague does.

In Basel the community is locked into a wooden building on an island in the Rhine and burned. In Erfurt three thousand die in one day. In Mainz six thousand fight back and are destroyed.

More than two hundred Jewish communities are annihilated in three years.

The chronicler Jacob von Konigshofen recorded what Strasbourg did next.

Jacob von Konigshofen · Strasbourg Chronicle · c. 1349

“The money was divided among the artisans. The council took the cash that the Jews possessed and divided the debts owed to the Jews among the citizens.”

Map showing the chronological progression of plague across Europe, from its arrival in Sicily in October 1347 through its spread to Scandinavia and Russia by 1351.
Map showing the chronological progression of plague across Europe, from its arrival in Sicily in October 1347 through its spread to Scandinavia and Russia by 1351.Flappiefh, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (2020)

Scene 5One to two pence a day

Before the plague an English laborer with no land earned one to two pence a day. There were more people than land, so the lord set the wage.

About four in ten English peasants were villeins. A villein could not leave the manor, or marry, or sell land, without the lord's permission.

Then a third to a half of the country died, and by thirteen fifty one some farm workers were earning double and triple what they had been paid.

Parliament, the landlord class, passed the Statute of Laborers in thirteen fifty one, fixing wages at the thirteen forty six level and making refusal of the old rate a crime.

The manor court records show those same lords competing for workers with higher wages, free meals and lighter obligations, while backing the law in public.

Five accounts

Five accounts of this, and they are not five theories about what killed people. That question closed in a laboratory in two thousand and eleven.

  1. The Christian west
  2. Islamic medicine
  3. The Jewish communities
  4. The peasants and laborers
  5. The Mongol road

The turn

And here is what each of them cannot account for.

  1. European Christian: Divine Punishment

    The Christian account explains the flagellants and the emptied monasteries honestly. It has nothing to say about the physicians in Granada who had the mechanism right while Paris read the planets, and it does not look at what its own cities did in those years.

    From the record
    Rational medical approaches attempted by Arab and some European physicians
    Economic consequences and labor market transformation
    Persecution of Jews as a social response to the crisis
    Plague's origins in Central Asia and its movement along trade routes
  2. Islamic Medical: Contagion Before Germ Theory

    The Islamic medical account is proud of putting evidence above doctrine, and it has earned that. It passes quickly over the teaching that a Muslim must not leave a plague stricken land, which the same account elsewhere credits as a crude quarantine.

    From the record
    European medical responses and institutional innovations (quarantine systems)
    Christian theological frameworks and cultural responses
    The plague's impact on European labor markets and feudalism
    Jewish persecution across Europe during the plague years
  3. Jewish Community: Scapegoats and Survivors

    The Jewish account has the fewest survivors and the clearest documents, and it leaves out everything that is not the persecution. The medicine. The labor collapse. The Christians dying in the same streets. Its own record shows a pope ordering the killing to stop, so the Church was never one actor.

    From the record
    Medical and scientific aspects of plague transmission
    Christian suffering and theological crisis during the pandemic
    Labor market transformation and peasant empowerment
    Non-European experiences of the plague
  4. Peasant and Laborer: The Great Leveling

    The peasants' account has the weakest causation, and its honest version admits it. Robert Brenner's point is that the identical shock produced opposite results. In eastern Europe the landlords tightened the bonds instead, and the second serfdom ran five more centuries. It also tells a whole century with no priest and no burned community in it.

    From the record
    Religious and theological dimensions of the plague experience
    Medical knowledge and public health responses
    Jewish persecution and scapegoating
    Urban and commercial impacts distinct from agricultural labor
  5. Mongol Trade Route: The Silk Road Pandemic

    The Mongol account is the widest and the least certain. Its most repeated scene may not have happened as told. Gabriele de Mussi may never have been at Caffa, and the plague was probably already inside the walls, in the rats.

    From the record
    European religious, cultural, and theological responses to the plague
    Jewish persecution and scapegoating across European cities
    Labor market transformation and the decline of serfdom
    Long-term institutional and political changes within European states

Close

Venice set forty days of isolation and called it the quarantina. The practice is still named after the number.

England did not have its people back until the sixteenth century.

And in Nuremberg, the council cleared the ground where the Jewish quarter had been and built a marketplace on it. The market is still there. It is called the Hauptmarkt.

The record

By the numbers

Span
15 yrs1346-1353
Killed
75-200Macross Eurasia and North Africa, estimates vary; recent…
Displaced
Killed 30-60% of Europe's population…
Place
Multiple

Key figures

  • Giovanni BoccaccioFlorentine author who witnessed the plague and recorded it in the Decameron (1353)1313 to 1375
  • Ibn KhatimaAndalusian physician who identified contagion as the mechanism of plague transmission (1349)1369 to ?
  • Guy de ChauliacPersonal physician to Pope Clement VI in Avignon; treated plague victims and survived1300 to 1368
  • Pope Clement VIHead of the Catholic Church during the plague; issued papal bulls against Jewish persecution1291 to 1352
  • al-MaqriziMamluk historian who documented the plague's devastation in Cairo and Egypt1364 to 1442
  • Ibn al-KhatibAndalusian polymath who argued plague spread by contagion, against prevailing miasma theory1313 to 1374

Primary sources

Giovanni Boccaccio · The Decameron, Introduction to the First Day · 1353

“How many valiant men, how many fair ladies, took breakfast with their kinfolk and that same night supped with their ancestors in the other world!”

Ibn Khaldun · Muqaddimah · 1377

“The plague penetrated the seas through Crimea and killed most of the people there. It then crossed into Sicily, Sardinia, and the rest of Europe, covering it all.”

Agnolo di Tura · Sienese Chronicle · c. 1348

“There was no one who wept for any death, for all awaited death.”