Skip to main content
c. 1440-1455

The Gutenberg Revolution

A bankrupt goldsmith copied a Buddhist idea and accidentally ended the Catholic Church's monopoly on truth

NYC Wanderer (Kevin Eng), CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Open

Two things about the man whose name is on this.

He did not invent printing. Chinese printers had been working from carved blocks since the ninth century. A man called Bi Sheng was setting movable ceramic characters around ten forty. Korean foundries were casting movable type in bronze by the twelve thirties, and the oldest surviving book printed that way came off a press at a Buddhist temple in thirteen seventy seven, seventy eight years before anything was printed in Mainz.

And he did not keep it. Within months of finishing the Bible that carries his name, Johannes Gutenberg lost the press, the type and the unsold stock in a lawsuit, to the man who had lent him the money.

Scene 1The judgement

Mainz, November fourteen fifty five. Johann Fust, a wealthy financier, goes to court against the printer he has been funding for five years.

The first loan was eight hundred guilders, in fourteen fifty, secured against the printing equipment. Two years later, another eight hundred.

Fust wants two thousand and twenty six guilders back, principal and compounded interest. He wins.

He takes the workshop, the type and the inventory. He takes Gutenberg's foreman, Peter Schoffer, who is also his son in law.

Fust and Schoffer become the first commercial publishers in Europe. They put their names in the books.

Gutenberg is granted a small pension by the Archbishop about ten years later, and dies in fourteen sixty eight.

The invention worked. That is why he lost it.

A machine that turns three years of labour into a hundred and eighty identical books is collateral worth seizing, and the person who understood that first was the creditor.

Scene 2The system

What was actually invented in Mainz was not a machine. It was a set of four things that had to work together.

An alloy of lead, tin and antimony that was soft enough to cast, hard enough to survive thousands of impressions, and that did not shrink as it cooled.

A hand mould that let one worker cast hundreds of identical letters a day.

An oil based ink, taken from what Flemish painters were doing, because the water based inks used for woodblocks simply slid off metal.

And a press, adapted from the screw presses that the Rhine valley used for wine.

Every one of those existed already. The combination did not.

The forty two line Bible was the demonstration. Two columns, forty two lines a page, in a typeface cut to imitate the best handwriting of the day, using about two hundred and ninety different characters to reproduce the abbreviations and the ligatures a scribe would use.

It took roughly three years. It used the skins of about a hundred and seventy calves per copy on the vellum editions.

And early readers could not tell the pages from manuscript, which was the point.

Nineteen years later, a Carthusian monk called Werner Rolewinck put the invention into a world chronicle, which was itself printed.

Werner Rolewinck · Fasciculus Temporum · 1474

“This art was discovered in Mainz, Germany. It is the art of arts, the science of sciences.”

A leaf from the Gutenberg Bible showing the dense blackletter textura typeface in two columns of 42 lines each. Rubrication and illuminated initials were added by hand after printing.
A leaf from the Gutenberg Bible showing the dense blackletter textura typeface in two columns of 42 lines each. Rubrication and illuminated initials were added by hand after printing.NYC Wanderer (Kevin Eng), CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons (2009)

Scene 3Fifty years

Now the numbers, because the speed is the whole story.

By fourteen seventy there are presses in Italy, France, the Netherlands and England. By fourteen eighty, in a hundred and ten towns. By fifteen hundred there are print shops in two hundred cities.

The output by fifteen hundred is about twenty seven thousand separate editions, somewhere near twenty million volumes.

In fourteen fifty, all the manuscripts in Europe together are estimated at perhaps thirty thousand books.

Within fifty years the price of a book falls by about eighty per cent. Over the next century and a half, literacy in western Europe goes from somewhere between five and ten in a hundred to thirty or forty.

Scene 4Wittenberg

The thirty first of October, fifteen seventeen. A theology professor in Wittenberg puts ninety five propositions about the sale of indulgences on a church door, in Latin, for other academics.

Within a fortnight printers in Nuremberg, Leipzig and Basel have reprinted them. Within three months there are an estimated three hundred thousand copies in circulation, in German.

Martin Luther did not translate them. Printers did, because there was a market.

Between fifteen seventeen and fifteen twenty five, German presses turn out around six thousand pamphlet titles. Eight to sixteen pages, a few pfennigs, woodcut illustrations for people who could not read the text.

Luther published thirty works in fifteen twenty alone. He knew exactly what he was holding.

Luther, at his own table, years later.

Martin Luther · Table Talk · c. 1530

“Printing is the ultimate gift of God and the greatest one.”

Idealized 16th-century portrait. No contemporary likeness of Gutenberg survives. The inventor of the European printing press left no portrait, no personal letters, and no diary.
Idealized 16th-century portrait. No contemporary likeness of Gutenberg survives. The inventor of the European printing press left no portrait, no personal letters, and no diary.Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (16th century)

Five accounts

Five ways of telling this, and they disagree about what the invention even was.

  1. The printers
  2. The Catholic Church
  3. The Chinese and Korean precedent
  4. The pamphlet war
  5. The information theorists
A working replica of a 15th-century wooden screw press, adapted from Rhine Valley winemaking presses. The flat platen distributed even pressure across the forme of set type.
A working replica of a 15th-century wooden screw press, adapted from Rhine Valley winemaking presses. The flat platen distributed even pressure across the forme of set type.William Small, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (2004)

The turn

And here is the shape of what each account is not saying.

  1. Gutenberg and the Printer's Revolution

    The printers' account leaves out that every component was borrowed, from the winemakers, the goldsmiths and the painters, and that the man who assembled them could not hold on to the result.

    From the record
    Chinese and Korean precedents in movable type centuries earlier
    Gutenberg's business failures and Fust's role as the actual commercial publisher
    The social disruption, from unemployment of scribes to monastic copying houses made obsolete
    Print's role in enabling propaganda, censorship evasion, and misinformation
  2. Catholic Church

    The Church's account leaves out that it paid for the first presses and profited from them, and that the indulgences the Reformation attacked were among the first things Gutenberg printed.

    From the record
    Church's own enthusiastic early adoption and patronage of printing
    Legitimate concerns about doctrinal accuracy and theological error in mass-produced texts
    Print's role in spreading anti-Semitic and other harmful content alongside reform literature
    The intellectual quality of many banned works versus the crude propaganda that also circulated
  3. Chinese and Korean Precedent

    The Chinese and Korean account, which is right about priority, can let priority stand in for consequence. The Jikji proves who was first. It does not explain why the technology stayed local there and travelled here, which is the question the alphabet answers.

    From the record
    Gutenberg's genuine systemic innovation, the integrated press, ink, and alloy system
    Practical limitations of logographic movable type that constrained Chinese adoption
    The demonstrable difference in societal impact between East Asian and European printing
    Europe's unique political fragmentation, which prevented centralized suppression and accelerated print's spread
  4. Reformation and the Pamphlet Wars

    The pamphlet account leaves out that the same presses served whoever paid, and that the Index of Forbidden Books is as much a child of printing as the Reformation is.

    From the record
    Print's role in spreading Counter-Reformation materials and Catholic devotional literature
    Commercial motivations of printers who published whatever sold, regardless of theology
    Print-enabled propaganda that fueled the German Peasants' War (1524-1525) and its 100,000 dead
    The wars of religion (1524-1648) that print helped ignite and sustain
  5. Information Revolution Theory

    And the theorists' account leaves out the people. It is a description of properties. There is no goldsmith in it, and no lawsuit.

    From the record
    Oral culture's persistence and resilience alongside print; most Europeans remained illiterate for centuries
    Non-European print traditions and their independent impacts
    The economic exploitation of print workers: compositors, press operators, booksellers
    Women's near-total exclusion from the printing trade and authorship until the 18th century
The final page of the Jikji, a Korean Buddhist text printed with metal movable type at Heungdeok Temple in 1377, 78 years before Gutenberg's Bible. The only surviving copy is held at the Bibliotheque nationale de France.
The final page of the Jikji, a Korean Buddhist text printed with metal movable type at Heungdeok Temple in 1377, 78 years before Gutenberg's Bible. The only surviving copy is held at the Bibliotheque nationale de France.Zythème, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons (1377)

Close

Fust and Schoffer's books are the first with a printer's name, a date and a place on the last page. Gutenberg's Bible has none of that on it. It is anonymous.

The Index of Forbidden Books was maintained for four hundred and seven years, and abolished in nineteen sixty six.

The pension that kept Gutenberg was paid in grain, wine and cloth.

And the oldest surviving book printed with metal type sits in a library in Paris, four and a half thousand miles from the temple that made it.

The record

By the numbers

Span
50 yrs
Killed
N/A, cultural revolution, though…
Displaced
20MTransformed literacy from elite privilege to mass…
Place
Holy Roman Empire (Mainz)

Key figures

  • Johannes GutenbergInventor of the European movable-type printing systemc. 1400 to 1468
  • Johann FustFinancier who sued Gutenberg, seized his press, and became Europe's first commercial publisherc. 1400 to 1466
  • Peter SchöfferGutenberg's apprentice and Fust's son-in-law, continued printing after the lawsuitc. 1425 to 1503
  • Bi ShengChinese inventor of movable ceramic type, c. 1040c. 990 to c. 1051
  • Martin LutherReformer whose 95 Theses became the first viral printed document1483 to 1546
  • Aldus ManutiusVenetian printer who invented the pocket-sized book (octavo format)1449 to 1515

Primary sources

Martin Luther · Table Talk · c. 1530

“Printing is the ultimate gift of God and the greatest one.”

Werner Rolewinck · Fasciculus Temporum (first printed world chronicle) · 1474

“This art was discovered in Mainz, Germany. It is the art of arts, the science of sciences.”

Dominican friar at the Council of Trent (attributed) · Quoted in Eisenstein, The Printing Press as an Agent of Change · c. 1546

“Let us break their bonds asunder and cast away their yokes from us — now the common people have the Bible, and the heretics will cite texts.”