Skip to main content
2nd century BCE - 15th century CE

The Silk Road

A Roman woman wore Chinese silk without either empire knowing the other existed

World Imaging, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Open

Two things about the name.

It was invented in eighteen seventy seven, by a German geographer, about four hundred years after the thing it describes had stopped working. Nobody who ever travelled it called it that.

And there was no road. There was no single route, no surface, no map. There was a shifting braid of paths that moved with the politics, and the cargo that mattered most on it was not silk.

Scene 1A failed diplomat

One hundred and thirty eight years before the common era. A Han official named Zhang Qian leaves the capital with a hundred men and one instruction: find a people called the Yuezhi, somewhere far to the west, and make them allies against the nomads raiding the northern frontier.

Within a year he is captured by exactly those nomads.

He stays with them for ten years. He marries a Xiongnu woman. He has a son. Then he escapes, and continues west, because he still has the instruction.

He reaches the Ferghana valley. He crosses into Bactria. He finds the Yuezhi, who are settled, comfortable, and completely uninterested in a war.

He gets home in one hundred and twenty five, thirteen years after leaving, with one of his hundred men. The mission was a total failure.

What he brought back instead was a report, and one detail in it changed the empire's picture of the world.

In the markets of Bactria he had seen cloth and bamboo from Sichuan. Chinese goods, thousands of miles west, arrived through India, years before any Chinese official had gone looking.

The routes already existed. What Zhang Qian did was not discover them. It was make them visible to a court that could fund them.

The historian Sima Qian wrote his report down two generations later, and this is Zhang Qian describing what lay to the south.

Zhang Qian (as recorded by Sima Qian) · Records of the Grand Historian · ~90 BCE

“From the capital of the Yuezhi kingdom it is possible to go south to the kingdom of Shendu. The people there are numerous and sedentary, and their customs are similar to those of the Yuezhi.”

A Greco-Buddhist sculpture from Gandhara (modern Pakistan) showing the Buddha with Greek-style drapery and Indian iconographic hand positions. This artistic synthesis traveled the Silk Road to shape all East Asian Buddhist art.
A Greco-Buddhist sculpture from Gandhara (modern Pakistan) showing the Buddha with Greek-style drapery and Indian iconographic hand positions. This artistic synthesis traveled the Silk Road to shape all East Asian Buddhist art.World Imaging, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (2nd-3rd century CE)

Scene 2What actually moved

Silk went west, and it is the cargo the west noticed, because it was the one the rich were spending on.

Pliny the Elder, in Rome, filed the complaint that every empire eventually files about its own imports.

Pliny the Elder · Natural History, Book XII · 77 CE

“By the lowest reckoning, India, China, and the Arabian peninsula take from our empire one hundred million sesterces every year. That is the sum which our luxuries and our women cost us.”

Scene 3Paper, powder, and the compass

But the freight that changed things was not the luxury.

Paper went west. Gunpowder went west. The magnetic compass went west. Glassmaking went east, out of Rome and Persia. Cotton went in both directions. The Chinese lute, the pipa, is a Persian instrument that walked.

And religions moved as cargo moves, with the people carrying the goods. Buddhism went from India into China across Central Asia over five centuries. Nestorian Christians reached the Tang capital in six hundred and thirty five, and carved a stone in Xi'an in seven eighty one to say so. Manichaeism came out of Persia and became a state religion on the steppe. Islam went east along the same roads.

The geography was never one line. A northern route ran around the Taklamakan desert through the oasis towns, Turpan, Kucha, Kashgar, then climbed the Pamirs. A southern route hugged the other edge through Khotan, where jade had been traded since three thousand years before Christ. And there was a sea route, from Guangzhou to the Persian Gulf and down the coast of East Africa.

At the Tang peak the overland network ran about six thousand four hundred kilometres, and the sea route roughly doubled it.

Map showing the principal overland and maritime routes connecting Chang''an to Rome, including the northern and southern routes around the Taklamakan Desert, the maritime route through the Indian Ocean, and the major trading cities along the way.
Map showing the principal overland and maritime routes connecting Chang''an to Rome, including the northern and southern routes around the Taklamakan Desert, the maritime route through the Indian Ocean, and the major trading cities along the way.Whole_world_-_land_and_oceans_12000.jpg: NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center derivative work: Splette, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (2007)

Five accounts

Five accounts of one network, and none of them is a story about a road.

  1. The Chinese court
  2. The Sogdians
  3. The Buddhist transmission
  4. The Islamic golden age
  5. The disease road
The three madrasas of Registan Square in Samarkand, Uzbekistan, heart of Sogdian and later Timurid trade. Timur rebuilt Samarkand in the late 14th century using craftsmen forcibly relocated from Damascus, Delhi, and Isfahan.
The three madrasas of Registan Square in Samarkand, Uzbekistan, heart of Sogdian and later Timurid trade. Timur rebuilt Samarkand in the late 14th century using craftsmen forcibly relocated from Damascus, Delhi, and Isfahan.Steve Evans (babasteve) from India and USA, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons (2005)

The turn

And what each account cannot hold.

  1. Chinese Imperial

    The imperial account leaves out the traders. When every exchange is written down as tribute flowing to the centre, the people who actually moved the goods appear only as foreigners being permitted.

    From the record
    Sogdian, Turkic, and Persian merchants who actually operated the trade networks
    Central Asian oasis states'' autonomous role in facilitating exchange
    Chinese goods reaching Bactria before Zhang Qian arrived; trade preceded imperial awareness
    Environmental costs of Silk Road agriculture, including deforestation and desertification of the Tarim Basin
  2. Central Asian / Sogdian

    The Sogdian account survives as contracts, which is precise about prices and silent about everything else. We know their exchange rates. We do not know what they thought they were building.

    From the record
    Chinese and Roman imperial perspectives that frame the Silk Road as their achievement
    Military and diplomatic dimensions controlled by empires, not merchants
    Sogdian involvement in slave trading along the routes
    Environmental transformation of oasis agriculture that made the routes possible
  3. Buddhist Transmission

    The Buddhist account runs on a few extraordinary travellers, and a handful of heroic journeys is a bad model for a transmission that took five centuries and was carried mostly by people whose names are gone.

    From the record
    Commercial motivations of Buddhist monasteries, which functioned as banks and hostels along trade routes
    Violent suppression of Buddhism in China under Emperor Wuzong (845 CE)
    Buddhist institutions'' role in legitimizing political authority along the routes
    Decline of Buddhism in India itself, its country of origin
  4. Islamic Golden Age

    The golden age account is usually told from the far end, as the route by which Greek learning reached Europe, which measures Baghdad by what it forwarded instead of what it made.

    From the record
    Arab conquest of Central Asia destroyed indigenous Sogdian and Zoroastrian cultures
    Forced conversion and political coercion that accompanied the spread of Islam along trade routes
    The slave trade (the Silk Road carried human beings as well as silk)
    Environmental degradation from agricultural intensification around oasis cities
  5. Disease Vector / Ecological

    And the disease account, told alone, turns a network into a villain. The connection that moved the plague is the same connection that moved paper. There is no version of this where you get one and not the other.

    From the record
    Cultural and intellectual achievements transmitted along the same routes
    Millions of people for whom Silk Road trade meant prosperity, not pestilence
    Local disease management and quarantine practices in Silk Road cities
    Modern Silk Road nostalgia in Belt and Road Initiative rhetoric

One line, and a warning about it. Marco Polo is supposed to have said this as he was dying, and the only source is a chronicler writing it down afterwards, so it may be something he never said.

Marco Polo · Attributed deathbed remark · 1324

“I have not told half of what I saw.”

Close

The network did not collapse. It atrophied.

In fourteen ninety eight Vasco da Gama reached India by sea and cut out every middleman between Lisbon and Calicut. A ship carries more than a camel and does not need to be fed across a desert, and bulk trade went to the water.

The name arrived four centuries after that, from a geographer in Berlin who never walked it.

And the letters that a Sogdian woman wrote to a husband who had stopped answering spent sixteen hundred years in a watchtower on the frontier, in a language that had no readers left, before anyone opened them.

The record

By the numbers

Span
1,600 yrs
Displaced
Connected civilizations from Chang'an…
Place
Multiple

Key figures

  • Zhang QianHan dynasty explorer who opened diplomatic contact with Central Asia (138-125 BCE)-200 to -114
  • XuanzangBuddhist monk who traveled from Tang China to India (629-645 CE), author of Great Tang Records on the Western Regions602 to 664
  • Marco PoloVenetian merchant who traveled to the court of Kublai Khan (1271-1295)1254 to 1324
  • Genghis KhanFounded Mongol Empire (1206), whose Pax Mongolica revived overland trade1162 to 1227
  • Timur (Tamerlane)Turco-Mongol conqueror who controlled Central Asian trade routes (1370-1405)1336 to 1405

Primary sources

Pliny the Elder · Natural History, Book XII · 77 CE

“By the lowest reckoning, India, China, and the Arabian peninsula take from our empire 100 million sesterces every year — that is the sum which our luxuries and our women cost us.”

Zhang Qian (as recorded by Sima Qian) · Records of the Grand Historian (Shiji), Chapter 123 · ~90 BCE

“From the capital of the Yuezhi kingdom it is possible to go south to the kingdom of Shendu [India]. The people there are numerous and sedentary, and their customs are similar to those of the Yuezhi.”

Marco Polo · Attributed deathbed remark, recorded by Jacopo d''Acqui · 1324

“I have not told half of what I saw.”